| Toby Keith - Unleashed (HDCD, Album) (Very Good (VG)) | CA$2.00 | Mile High Vinyl |
| Toby Keith - Does That Blue Moon Ever Shine On You (7", Single) (Very Good (VG)) | CA$2.00 | Mile High Vinyl |
| Toby Keith - You Ain't Much Fun (7") (Good Plus (G+)) | CA$2.00 | Mile High Vinyl |
| Toby Keith – How Do You Like Me Now?! (CD) | $2.99 | Hi-Fi Hits |
| Toby Keith - Toby Keith (CD, Album, Club) (Very Good Plus (VG+)) | CA$3.00 | Mile High Vinyl |
| Toby Keith - Greatest Hits Volume One (CD, Comp, Club) (Near Mint (NM or M-)) | CA$3.00 | Mile High Vinyl |
| Toby Keith - Unleashed [CD CD] (VG) | $3.99 | Endless Media |
| Toby Keith - Honkytonk University [CD CD] (VG) | $3.99 | Endless Media |
| TOBY KEITH - BIG DOG DADDY | CA$4.00 | ID Shop.ca |
| Toby Keith - The Best Of Toby Keith (CD) (NM or M-, VG+) | $4.00 | Nail City Record |
| Toby Keith - Blue Moon (CD) (NM or M-, VG+) | $4.50 | Nail City Record |
| Toby Keith - Greatest Hits 2 [CD CD] (VG+) | $4.99 | Endless Media |
| Toby Keith - Unleashed [CD CD] (VG+) | $4.99 | Endless Media |
| Toby Keith - Honkytonk University (CD, Album) (Very Good Plus (VG+)) | CA$5.00 | Mile High Vinyl |
| Toby Keith - Blue Moon (CD) (NM or M-, VG+) | $5.00 | Nail City Record |
| Toby Keith - Unleashed (HDCD, Album) (Near Mint (NM or M-)) | CA$5.00 | Mile High Vinyl |
| Toby Keith - If A Man Answers (7", Single) (Very Good Plus (VG+)) | CA$8.00 | Mile High Vinyl |
| Toby Keith - Blue Moon [Cassette Cassette] (VG+) | $8.99 | Endless Media |
| Toby Keith - American Soldier (7", Single) (Very Good Plus (VG+)) | CA$10.00 | Mile High Vinyl |
| Toby Keith - Peso In My Pocket - CD | €13.00 | Encore Records Ltd |
| Toby Keith – Toby Keith (CD, Album, Club) (Near Mint (NM or M-)) | CA$13.06 | Record Collectors Paradise |
| Toby Keith - 13 Number Ones [CD] | $13.99 | soldoutvinylrecords |
| Toby Keith - 13 Number Ones [CD] | $13.99 | Out of the Past Records |
| Toby Keith - 13 Number Ones [CD] | $15.99 | Latchkey |
| Toby Keith - 13 Number Ones [CD] | $15.99 | Factory Records |
| Toby Keith - 35 Biggest Hits [CD] | $16.00 | Spinster Records |
| Toby Keith - 13 Number Ones [CD] | $16.99 | South Metro Music |
| Toby Keith - 13 Number Ones [CD] | $17.99 | Strictly |
| Toby Keith 35 Biggest Hits (2 Cd's) | $21.99 | Music Record Shop |
| Toby Keith - Should've Been A Cowboy (25TH Anniversary Edition) | $21.99 | Strictly |
| Toby Keith - Peso In My Pocket (LP Vinyl) | $23.98 | Nail City Record |
| Toby Keith - 13 Number Ones [LP] | $27.99 | Out of the Past Records |
| Toby Keith - 100% Songwriter [LP] | $27.99 | Out of the Past Records |
| Toby Keith - 13 Number Ones [VINYL LP] | $28.00 | Luna Record Shop |
| Toby Keith 100% Songwriter [LP] | $28.47 | Music Record Shop |
| Toby Keith – 13 Number Ones | $29.98 | REB Records |
| Toby Keith - 100% Songwriter [LP] | $29.99 | South Metro Music |
| Toby Keith - Should've Been A Cowboy: 25th Anniversary Edition [LP] | $29.99 | Out of the Past Records |
| Toby Keith - 13 Number Ones [LP] | $29.99 | South Metro Music |
| Toby Keith - should’ve been a cowboy | $30.95 | Sessions Vinyl Room |
| Toby Keith Christmas To Christmas [Translucent Green LP] | $30.99 | Music Record Shop |
| Toby Keith - Christmas To Christmas LP (Green Vinyl) | $31.00 | Eroding Winds |
| Toby Keith - Should've Been A Cowboy: 25th Anniversary Edition [LP] | $31.99 | South Metro Music |
| Toby Keith - 100% Songwriter (Vinyl LP) | $32.00 | Luna Record Shop |
| Toby Keith - Should've Been A Cowboy (Vinyl LP) | $33.00 | Luna Record Shop |
| Toby Keith - Should Have Been A Cowboy (25th Anniversary Edition) (Mint (M)) Folk World & Country (LP, Album, RE, RM) | $34.98 | soldoutvinylrecords |
| Toby Keith - I Love This Bar (7", Single) (Very Good (VG)) | CA$44.00 | Mile High Vinyl |
| Toby Keith - Should've been a cowboy (LP) | €49.95 | Discords.nl |
| Toby Keith - 35 Biggest Hits (Vinyl 3LP) | $59.00 | Luna Record Shop |
| Toby Keith – 100% Songwriter (Red, White, Blue Splatter Vinyl) | $59.98 | Hi-Fi Hits |
| Toby Keith - 35 Biggest Hits [LP] | $59.99 | Out of the Past Records |
| Toby Keith - 35 Biggest Hits [LP] | $61.00 | Musicology Co |
| Toby Keith - 35 Biggest Hits [LP] | $73.99 | South Metro Music |
| Toby Keith - 35 Biggest Hits | $79.99 | Rock City Music Co. |
LP/EP Finder