| Shudder To Think – Music From The Motion Picture First Love, Last Rites LP | $9.99 | Strictly |
| SHUDDER TO THINK – THIRST WALK (PINK VINYL) - 7" • | $9.99 | Lunchbox Records |
| SHUDDER TO THINK - THIRST WALK | £11.39 | Dreamhouse Records |
| Shudder To Think - Pony Express Record | $12.00 | Rewind Records |
| Shudder To Think - Thirst walk (opaque pink) (7-inch single) | €13.99 | Sounds Haarlem |
| SHUDDER TO THINK / FIRST LOVE, LAST RITES LP | $14.49 | Feel It Records |
| Shudder To Think – First Love Last Rites (LP) (RSD 2025) | $14.50 | Spin Time Records |
| Shudder To Think – “First Love, Last Rites OST” (Released 12th April 2025) | £14.99 | Pie & Vinyl |
| SHUDDER TO THINK – FIRST LOVE LAST RITES - O.S.T. (RSD25) - LP • | $24.99 | Lunchbox Records |
| Shudder To Think – Music From The Motion Picture First Love, Last Rites | €25.50 | Fresh Garbage Records |
| Shudder To Think – Music From The Motion Picture First Love, Last Rites | €25.50 | Fresh Garbage Records |
| SHUDDER TO THINK – 1987 DEMO (180 GRAM) - LP • | $25.99 | Lunchbox Records |
| Shudder To Think – 1987 (LP) | $26.00 | Spin Time Records |
| Shudder To Think - First Love Last Rites LP NEW RSD 2025 | $26.99 | Hi-Voltage Records |
| Shudder To Think - First Love, Last Rites: Music From The Motion Picture (RSD 2025) (New Vinyl) | CA$27.00 | Sonic Boom |
| Shudder to Think - First Love Last Rites | $27.99 | Saint Marie Records |
| SHUDDER TO THINK – First Love, Last Rites (OST) RSD LP | €28.00 | Dirty Old Shop |
| Shudder to Think – 1987 (180 Gram Vinyl) | $29.98 | Hi-Fi Hits |
| Shudder to Think – First Love Last Rites (Music From The Motion Picture) (RSD Exclusive, 140 Gram Vinyl) | $29.98 | Hi-Fi Hits |
| Shudder to Think - First Love Last Rites | $29.99 | Good Records To Go |
| Shudder To Think - Pony Express Record | $30.00 | South Metro Music |
| Shudder To Think - 1987 | $31.99 | Goner Records |
| SHUDDER TO THINK : First Love, Last Rites Music From The Motion Picture | CA$31.99 | Argy's Rock and Entertainment |
| Shudder To Think - First Love, Last Rites Music From The Motion Picture Vinyle, LP, RSD | CA$31.99 | Freeson Rock |
| SHUDDER TO THINK – PONY EXPRESS RECORD (EXPANDED EDITION CLEAR VINYL) (RSD25) - LP • | $31.99 | Lunchbox Records |
| Shudder To Think | Pony Express Record (Vinilo transparente) | €34.95 | Discos Alta Fidelidad |
| Shudder To Think – Pony Express Record (Clear) 2LP | $34.99 | Strictly |
| Shudder To Think - Pony Express Record (2LP) (RSD 2025) (New Vinyl) | CA$35.00 | Sonic Boom |
| Shudder To Think – Pony Express Record (Clear Vinyl 2LP) (RSD 2025) | $36.50 | Spin Time Records |
| Shudder To Think (1994) - Pony Express Record - New 2 LP Record Store Day 2025 Epic RSD Clear Vinyl - Alternative Rock / Post-Hardcore | $36.99 | Shuga Records |
| Shudder to Think - Pony Express Record | $36.99 | Good Records To Go |
| Shudder To Think – Pony Express Record 2xLP Record Store Day | €37.00 | Threechords Record Store |
| Shudder To Think - First Love, Last Rites – OST – New LP – RSD25 | £38.43 | Off The Beaten Tracks |
| Shudder To Think - First Love, Last Rites (OST) - 1LP - Black Vinyl [Record Store Day 2025] | £40.00 | Tangled Parrot |
| Shudder To Think - First Love, Last Rites OST | £41.19 | Mixed Up Records |
| Shudder To Think - Pony Express Record 2 x Vinyle, LP, RSD | CA$41.99 | Freeson Rock |
| Shudder To Think - Pony Express Record - 2LP - Ultra Clear Vinyl [Record Store Day 2025] | £42.00 | Tangled Parrot |
| Shudder To Think – Pony Express Record | €43.50 | Fresh Garbage Records |
| Shudder To Think – Pony Express Record | €43.50 | Fresh Garbage Records |
| Shudder To Think - Pony Express Record | 2xLP | €44.00 | Gold Soundz Dischi |
| Shudder To Think | Pony Express Record | €50.00 | Serendeepity |
| Shudder To Think - Pony Express Record – New Clear 2LP – RSD25 | £50.79 | Off The Beaten Tracks |
| SHUDDER TO THINK – PONY EXPRESS RECORD RSD 2025 clear vinyl LP2 | €55.00 | Dancing Bear |
| Shudder To Think - 1987 [Vinyl] | A$59.95 | Rocking Horse Records |
| Shudder To Think – X-French Tee Shirt (Vinyl Single) | SEK 75.00 | TidensTempo |
| Shudder To Think - Pony Express Record [Vinyl] | A$79.95 | Rocking Horse Records |
| Shudder To Think – First Love, Last Rites Music From The Motion Picture [LTD LP] (RSD25) | NOK 250.00 | All Good Clean Records |
| Shudder To Think – Ten-Spot (Color Vinyl LP) | SEK 259.00 | TidensTempo |
| Shudder To Think – Pony Express Record [LTD 2xLP] (RSD25) | NOK 300.00 | All Good Clean Records |
| Shudder To Think – Pony Express Record (2 x Clear Vinyl LP) | SEK 445.00 | TidensTempo |
| Shudder To Think - First Love, Last Rites - OST LP (RSD 2025) | | Specialist Subject Records |
| Shudder To Think - Thirst Walk 7" | | Specialist Subject Records |
LP/EP Finder