| Natalie Merchant - Tigerlily [CD CD] (VG+) | $2.99 | Endless Media |
| Natalie Merchant - Motherland (CD) (NM or M-, VG+) | $3.00 | Nail City Record |
| Natalie Merchant - Ophelia (CD) (NM or M-, VG+) | $3.00 | Nail City Record |
| Natalie Merchant - Tigerlily (CD, Album, RP, ARC) VG+ | $3.00 | Love People Records |
| Natalie Merchant – Ophelia (CD) | $3.99 | Hi-Fi Hits |
| Natalie Merchant – Tigerlily CD VG+/VG+ | $4.00 | Out of the Past Records |
| Natalie Merchant - Tigerlily (CD) (NM or M-, VG+) | $4.50 | Nail City Record |
| Natalie Merchant – Motherland (CD, Album) (Near Mint (NM or M-)) | CA$5.46 | Record Collectors Paradise |
| Natalie Merchant – Motherland (CD, Album) (Near Mint (NM or M-)) | CA$5.50 | Record Collectors Paradise |
| Natalie Merchant - Tigerlily | $6.00 | Rewind Records |
| Natalie Merchant – Motherland (CD, Album) | €7.00 | Vinileria |
| Natalie Merchant – Ophelia (HDCD, Album) (Near Mint (NM or M-)) | CA$7.00 | Record Collectors Paradise |
| Natalie Merchant – Ophelia (HDCD, Album) (Near Mint (NM or M-)) | CA$7.00 | Record Collectors Paradise |
| Natalie Merchant – (Selections From The Album) Leave Your Sleep (CD, Album, gat) (Near Mint (NM or M-)) | CA$8.26 | Record Collectors Paradise |
| Natalie Merchant - Keep Your Courage | £13.99 | Dig In Records |
| Natalie Merchant - Keep Your Courage - CD | €15.00 | Encore Records Ltd |
| NATALIE MERCHANT - RETROSPECTIVE 1995-2005 - CD (NEW/ SEALED) | A$15.00 | Dixons Recycled |
| Natalie Merchant – Leave Your Sleep | €15.90 | Amadeus Dischi |
| Natalie Merchant - Keep Your Courage | £16.46 | Eclipse Records |
| Natalie Merchant - Retrospective 1995-2005 [CD] | $18.99 | Factory Records |
| Natalie Merchant - Leave Your Sleep (2xCD, Album, Med) (Mint (M)) | CA$19.00 | Mile High Vinyl |
| Natalie Merchant – Paradise Is There – The New Tigerlily Recordings | €19.90 | Amadeus Dischi |
| Natalie Merchant – Retrospective: 1995-2005 | €19.90 | Amadeus Dischi |
| Natalie Merchant - Retrospective 1995-2005 [CD] | $19.99 | Latchkey |
| Natalie Merchant - Motherland 180G Vinyl LP Reissue | £20.00 | Dig In Records |
| Natalie Merchant – Natalie Merchant (CD, Album, Gat) (Near Mint (NM or M-)) | CA$20.73 | Record Collectors Paradise |
| Natalie Merchant – Keep Your Courage | €20.90 | Amadeus Dischi |
| Natalie Merchant – Tigerlily (CD, Album) (Near Mint (NM or M-)) | CA$24.00 | Record Collectors Paradise |
| Natalie Merchant - Keep Your Courage - New LP 2023 Nonesuch Barnes & Noble Exclusive Gold Vinyl - Pop Rock | $34.99 | Shuga Records |
| Natalie Merchant Motherland [Import] (180 Gram Vinyl) | $36.64 | The Rock Shop |
| Natalie Merchant - Keep Your Courage | £36.99 | Sound Knowledge |
| Natalie Merchant - Paradise Is There (The New Tigerlily Recordings) (LP Tweedehands) | €37.95 | Discords.nl |
| Natalie Merchant - Motherland [Import] | $38.99 | South Metro Music |
| Natalie Merchant - Keep Your Courage (2LP) | $39.99 | Good Records To Go |
| Natalie Merchant - Keep Your Courage [2LP/ Bonus Tracks] | $39.99 | Morrow Records |
| Natalie Merchant - Keep Your Courage 2x Transparent Gold Vinyl LP | £39.99 | Dig In Records |
| Natalie Merchant - "Paradise Is There: The New Tigerlily Recordings" | $39.99 | ComebackVinyl.com |
| Natalie Merchant - Paradise Is There: The New Tigerlily Recordings [Vinyl] | $39.99 | Out of the Past Records |
| Natalie Merchant – Keep Your Courage (Vinyl) | €40.00 | MusicZone |
| Natalie Merchant - Keep Your Courage (2LP) | CA$40.15 | Compact Music |
| Natalie Merchant - Paradise Is There: The New Tigerlily Recordings [2LP] | $45.99 | Morrow Records |
| Natalie Merchant - Keep Your Courage | CA$46.99 | Red Cat Records |
| Natalie Merchant – Motherland | ZAR 50.00 | Vinyl Junkie |
| Natalie Merchant – Motherland | A$55.00 | Dutch Vinyl |
| Natalie Merchant – Tigerlily | MYR 290.00 | Teenage Head Records |
| Natalie Merchant – Motherland (VG+/VG) | ZAR 650.00 | Mr Vinyl |
| Natalie Merchant - Keep Your Courage [2LP] (140 Gram) | MX$1,100.00 | Musiclab* Records |
LP/EP Finder