| Johnny Mathis – Every Step Of The Way/No Man Can Stand Alone (7″ Vinyl) | $0.99 | Hi-Fi Hits |
| Johnny Mathis – Let’s Love / You Are Beautiful (7″ Vinyl) | $0.99 | Hi-Fi Hits |
| Johnny Mathis - The Christmas Music Of Johnny Mathis (A Personal Collection) (CD, Comp, RM) (NM or M-) | $1.00 | Sit and Spin Records |
| Johnny Mathis – Better Together – The Duet Album (CD, Album) (Near Mint (NM or M-)) | CA$1.74 | Record Collectors Paradise |
| Johnny Mathis / Deniece Williams – Too Much, Too Little, Too Late (7″, Single) | £1.94 | Lilley's Vinyl Revival |
| Johnny Mathis – Better Together – The Duet Album (CD) | $1.99 | Hi-Fi Hits |
| Johnny Mathis – Come To Me / When I Am With You (7″ Vinyl) | $1.99 | Hi-Fi Hits |
| Johnny Mathis – In The Still Of The Night (CD) | $1.99 | Hi-Fi Hits |
| Johnny Mathis – Johnny Mathis (7″ Vinyl EP) | $1.99 | Hi-Fi Hits |
| JOHNNY MATHIS - give me your love for Christmas | $2.00 | Northwest Grooves |
| Johnny Mathis - You Light Up My Life (LP, Album) (Good Plus (G+)) | CA$2.00 | Mile High Vinyl |
| Johnny Mathis – Come To Me (7″, EP, RP, 3-P) | £2.55 | Lilley's Vinyl Revival |
| Johnny Mathis - In Wisconsin / Sooner Or Later | £2.75 | Strummer Room Records |
| Johnny Mathis – Wild Is The Wind / No Love (But Your Love) (7″, Single, Promo) | £2.91 | Lilley's Vinyl Revival |
| Johnny Mathis - 16 Most Requested Songs [CD CD] (VG+) | $2.99 | Endless Media |
| Johnny Mathis - Christmas With Johnny Mathis [Cassette Cassette] (VG+) | $2.99 | Endless Media |
| Johnny Mathis - For Christmas [Cassette Cassette] (VG+) | $2.99 | Endless Media |
| Johnny Mathis - Have Yourself A Merry Little Christmas [Cassette Cassette] (VG+) | $2.99 | Endless Media |
| Johnny Mathis - In A Sentimental Mood: Mathis Sings Ellington [Cassette Cassette] (VG+) | $2.99 | Endless Media |
| Johnny Mathis – Johnny Mathis: 16 Most Requested Songs Encore! (CD) | $2.99 | Hi-Fi Hits |
| Johnny Mathis - Johnny Today (LP, Comp) (Very Good (VG)) | $2.99 | Paul Rose |
| Johnny Mathis - More Johnny's Greatest Hits (LP) (G) | $2.99 | Endless Media |
| Johnny Mathis – Once In A While (CD) | $2.99 | Hi-Fi Hits |
| Johnny Mathis - Winter Wonderland [CD CD] (VG+) | $2.99 | Endless Media |
| Johnny Mathis - Wonderful! Wonderful! (LP, Album, Mono) (Very Good (VG)) | $2.99 | Paul Rose |
| Johnny Mathis - Wonderful! Wonderful! (LP, Album, Mono) (Very Good (VG)) | $2.99 | Paul Rose |
| Johnny Mathis / 16 Most Requested Songs - CD (Used) | CA$3.00 | ID Shop.ca |
| Johnny Mathis - Good Night, Dear Lord (LP, Album, Mono) (Very Good Plus (VG+)) | CA$3.00 | Mile High Vinyl |
| Johnny Mathis - Right From The Heart (LP, Album) (Very Good (VG)) | CA$3.00 | Mile High Vinyl |
| Johnny Mathis - Stardust (7", Single, Promo) (Very Good Plus (VG+)) | CA$3.00 | Mile High Vinyl |
| Johnny Mathis – The First Time Ever (I Saw Your Face) | €3.00 | Simply-listening |
| Johnny Mathis – My Love For You (7″, EP, Mono) | £3.40 | Lilley's Vinyl Revival |
| Johnny Mathis – Canta En Español… Love Story (Vinyl) | €3.50 | Discos Comix |
| Johnny Mathis - Good Night, Dear Lord (LP, Album, RP) (Good (G)) | $3.99 | Paul Rose |
| Johnny Mathis - Heavenly (LP) (G+) | $3.99 | Endless Media |
| Johnny Mathis - Hold Me, Thrill Me, Kiss Me (LP, Album, Pit) (Good Plus (G+)) | $3.99 | Paul Rose |
| Johnny Mathis - Johnny (LP, Album, Mono) (Very Good (VG)) | $3.99 | Paul Rose |
| Johnny Mathis - Johnny's Greatest Hits (CD) (VG+) | $3.99 | Endless Media |
| Johnny Mathis - Killing Me Softly With Her Song (LP, Album) (Fair (F)) | $3.99 | Paul Rose |
| Johnny Mathis - Love Theme From "Romeo And Juliet" (A Time For Us) (LP, Album, Ter) (Good (G)) | $3.99 | Paul Rose |
| Johnny Mathis - The Christmas Music Of Johnny Mathis: A Personal Collection [CD CD] (VG+) | $3.99 | Endless Media |
| Johnny Mathis - The Shadow Of Your Smile (LP, Album, Ric) (Good Plus (G+)) | $3.99 | Paul Rose |
| Johnny Mathis - Wonderful! Wonderful! (LP, Album, Mono) (Good (G)) | $3.99 | Paul Rose |
| Johnny Mathis - I'm Stone In Love With You (7",45 RPM,Single) (Very Good Plus (VG+)) | €4.00 | Memories and Music Brielle |
| Johnny Mathis - Johnny’s Greatest Hits (Used - 12 inch) | $4.00 | For The Record |
| Johnny Mathis - Mathis Is... (LP, Album) (Very Good Plus (VG+)) | CA$4.00 | Mile High Vinyl |
| Johnny Mathis - Sending You A Little Christmas - CD | $4.00 | Record Town TX |
| Johnny Mathis - So Nice | £4.12 | Strummer Room Records |
| Johnny Mathis – Wonderfully Faithfull (2xCD, Comp) | £4.25 | Lilley's Vinyl Revival |
| Johnny Mathis - Misty (CD) (NM or M-, NM or M-) | $4.50 | Nail City Record |
| Johnny Mathis – The Ultimate Hits Collection (CD, Comp) (Near Mint (NM or M-)) | CA$4.62 | Record Collectors Paradise |
| Johnny Mathis – Wonderfully Faithfull (2xCD, Comp) | £4.82 | Lilley's Vinyl Revival |
| Johnny Mathis – Love Songs (CD, Comp) (Near Mint (NM or M-)) | CA$4.90 | Record Collectors Paradise |
| Johnny Mathis - Christmas Eve With Johnny Mathis [Cassette Cassette] (VG+) | $4.99 | Endless Media |
| Johnny Mathis - For Christmas [CD CD] (VG+) | $4.99 | Endless Media |
| Johnny Mathis - Friends In Love (LP, Album) (Good Plus (G+)) | $4.99 | Paul Rose |
| Johnny Mathis - Friends In Love - VG+ Cassette 1982 Columbia Tape - Rhythm & Blues | $4.99 | Shuga Records |
| Johnny Mathis - I'll Search My Heart (LP, Comp, Mono) (Very Good Plus (VG+)) | $4.99 | Paul Rose |
| Johnny Mathis - Johnny Mathis' All-Time Greatest Hits (2xLP, Comp, RE, Ter) (Very Good (VG)) | $4.99 | Paul Rose |
| Johnny Mathis - Johnny's Newest Hits (LP, Comp) (Very Good (VG)) | $4.99 | Paul Rose |
| Johnny Mathis - Live - VG+ Cassette 1984 Columbia Tape - Pop | $4.99 | Shuga Records |
| Johnny Mathis - Romantically (LP) (Very Good (VG)) | $4.99 | Paul Rose |
| Johnny Mathis - The Shadow Of Your Smile (LP, Album, Mono) (Very Good Plus (VG+)) | $4.99 | Paul Rose |
| Johnny Mathis – Gone, Gone, Gone / Begin The Beguine (12″, Maxi) | €5.00 | Djingel Djangel |
| Johnny Mathis - Johnny Mathis' Greatest Hits (7", EP, Mono) | A$5.00 | Daddy Rich Records |
| Johnny Mathis - Johnny’s Greatest Hits (Used - 12 inch) | $5.00 | For The Record |
| Johnny Mathis – More Johnny's Greatest Hits | CA$5.00 | Puce Rock |
| Johnny Mathis – 40th Anniversary Edition (4x CD) (Used CD) | $5.99 | Darkside Records |
| Johnny Mathis - Close To You (LP, Album, Ter) (Very Good Plus (VG+)) | $5.99 | Paul Rose |
| Johnny Mathis - Feelings (LP, Album) (Very Good (VG)) | $5.99 | Paul Rose |
| Johnny Mathis - Johnny's Newest Hits (LP, Comp, Mono, RE) (Near Mint (NM or M-)) | $5.99 | Paul Rose |
| Johnny Mathis - More Johnny's Greatest Hits (LP, Comp) (Very Good (VG)) | $5.99 | Paul Rose |
| Johnny Mathis - 16 Most Requested Songs - CD | $6.00 | Record Town TX |
| Johnny Mathis - Close To You - LP | $6.00 | Record Town TX |
| Johnny Mathis - Feelings - LP | $6.00 | Record Town TX |
| Johnny Mathis / Feelings - LP Used | CA$6.00 | ID Shop.ca |
| Johnny Mathis - Friends In Love - LP | $6.00 | Record Town TX |
| Johnny Mathis - Good Night, Dear Lord - LP | $6.00 | Record Town TX |
| Johnny Mathis - Good Night, Dear Lord - LP | $6.00 | Record Town TX |
| Johnny Mathis - Heavenly And Faithfully - LP | $6.00 | Record Town TX |
| Johnny Mathis - Heavenly - CD | $6.00 | Record Town TX |
| Johnny Mathis - Hold Me, Thrill Me, Kiss Me - LP | $6.00 | Record Town TX |
| Johnny Mathis - In A Sentimental Mood: Mathis Sings Ellington - CD | $6.00 | Record Town TX |
| Johnny Mathis - In A Sentimental Mood: Mathis Sings Ellington - CD | $6.00 | Record Town TX |
| Johnny Mathis - Johnny - LP | $6.00 | Record Town TX |
| Johnny Mathis - Johnny Mathis - CD | $6.00 | Record Town TX |
| Johnny Mathis - Johnny Mathis - LP | $6.00 | Record Town TX |
| Johnny Mathis - Johnny Mathis Sings - LP | $6.00 | Record Town TX |
| Johnny Mathis - Johnny Mathis Sings The Music Of Bacharach & Kaempfert - LP | $6.00 | Record Town TX |
| Johnny Mathis – Johnny's Greatest Hits | CA$6.00 | Puce Rock |
| Johnny Mathis - Johnny's Greatest Hits - CD | $6.00 | Record Town TX |
| Johnny Mathis – Johnny's Greatest Hits CD VG+/VG+ | $6.00 | Out of the Past Records |
| Johnny Mathis - Johnny's Newest Hits - LP | $6.00 | Record Town TX |
| Johnny Mathis - Killing Me Softly With Her Song - LP | $6.00 | Record Town TX |
| Johnny Mathis - Let It Be Me - Mathis In Nashville - CD | $6.00 | Record Town TX |
| Johnny Mathis - Love Is Blue - LP | $6.00 | Record Town TX |
| Johnny Mathis - Love Is Everything - LP | $6.00 | Record Town TX |
| Johnny Mathis - Love Story - LP | $6.00 | Record Town TX |
| Johnny Mathis - Love Theme From "Romeo And Juliet" (A Time For Us) - LP | $6.00 | Record Town TX |
| Johnny Mathis - Mathis Magic - LP | $6.00 | Record Town TX |
| Johnny Mathis - Mathis Magic - LP | $6.00 | Record Town TX |
| Johnny Mathis - Me And Mrs. Jones - LP | $6.00 | Record Town TX |
| Johnny Mathis - Me And Mrs. Jones - LP | $6.00 | Record Town TX |
| Johnny Mathis - Merry Christmas - LP | $6.00 | Record Town TX |
| Johnny Mathis - Olé - LP | $6.00 | Record Town TX |
| Johnny Mathis - Open Fire, Two Guitars - CD | $6.00 | Record Town TX |
| Johnny Mathis - Open Fire, Two Guitars - LP | $6.00 | Record Town TX |
| Johnny Mathis - Raindrops Keep Fallin’ On My Head (Used - 12 inch) | $6.00 | For The Record |
| Johnny Mathis - Rapture - LP | $6.00 | Record Town TX |
| Johnny Mathis - Romantically - LP | $6.00 | Record Town TX |
| Johnny Mathis - So Nice - LP | $6.00 | Record Town TX |
| Johnny Mathis - Song Sung Blue - LP | $6.00 | Record Town TX |
| Johnny Mathis - The Essential Johnny Mathis [Pre-Owned CD] | $6.00 | Josey Records |
| Johnny Mathis - The First 25 Years The Silver Anniversary Album | $6.00 | Record Town TX |
| Johnny Mathis - The First Time Ever (I Saw Your Face) - LP | $6.00 | Record Town TX |
| Johnny Mathis - The Heart Of A Woman - LP | $6.00 | Record Town TX |
| Johnny Mathis - The Impossible Dream - LP | $6.00 | Record Town TX |
| Johnny Mathis - The Rhythms And Ballads Of Broadway - LP | $6.00 | Record Town TX |
| Johnny Mathis - The Shadow Of Your Smile - LP | $6.00 | Record Town TX |
| Johnny Mathis - The Ultimate Hits Collection - CD | $6.00 | Record Town TX |
LP/EP Finder