| Father John Misty - Chloë and the Next 20th Century | £7.99 | Dig In Records |
| FATHER JOHN MISTY - CHLOË AND THE NEXT 20TH CENTURY (Cassette) | $8.99 | Good Records To Go |
| Father John Misty - I love you honeybear (CD) | €9.95 | Discords.nl |
| Father John Misty - Pure comedy (CD) | €9.95 | Discords.nl |
| FATHER JOHN MISTY – CHLOE & THE NEXT 20TH CENTURY - CD • | $9.99 | Lunchbox Records |
| FATHER JOHN MISTY – GOD'S FAVORITE CUSTOMER - TAPE • | $9.99 | Lunchbox Records |
| FATHER JOHN MISTY – I LOVE YOU HONEYBEAR - TAPE • | $9.99 | Lunchbox Records |
| Father John Misty – Pure Comedy Limited edition CD | $9.99 | Strictly |
| Father John Misty - Chloë and the Next 20th Century | £10.99 | Sound Knowledge |
| Father John Misty - God's Favorite Customer | $11.98 | Nice Price Books & Records |
| Father John Misty - I Love You, Honeybear | $11.98 | Nice Price Books & Records |
| Father John Misty - Pure Comedy | $11.98 | Nice Price Books & Records |
| Father John Misty – Chloë and The Next 20th Century Exclusive 2LP | $11.99 | Newbury Comics |
| Father John Misty – Chloe And The Next 20th Century (MC) | €11.99 | Pop-Eye / Velvet Music |
| Father John Misty - Fear fun (CD) | €11.99 | Sounds Haarlem |
| Father John Misty – Fear Fun CS | $11.99 | Feel It Records |
| Father John Misty - God's favorite customer -digi- (.. Customer, Digipak CD) | €11.99 | Sounds Haarlem |
| Father John Misty - I love you honeybear (CD) | €11.99 | Sounds Haarlem |
| Father John Misty - Mahashmashana | £11.99 | Sound Knowledge |
| FATHER JOHN MISTY – CHLOE & THE NEXT 20th CENTURA CD | €12.00 | Dancing Bear |
| Father John Misty - Fear Fun [Cassette] | $12.00 | Seasick Records |
| Father John Misty - I Love You, Honeybear [Cassette] | $12.00 | Seasick Records |
| Father John Misty - I Love You, Honeybear (CD, Album) (M / M) | £12.00 | Dig Vinyl |
| FATHER JOHN MISTY – CHLOË AND THE NEXT 20TH CENTURY | $12.99 | Get Hip Recordings! |
| FATHER JOHN MISTY / FEAR FUN CASSETTE | $12.99 | Rain Dog Records |
| FATHER JOHN MISTY – FEAR FUN - CD • | $12.99 | Lunchbox Records |
| FATHER JOHN MISTY – GREATISH HITS: I FOLLOWED MY DREAMS AND MY DREAMS SAID TO CRAWL - CD • | $12.99 | Lunchbox Records |
| FATHER JOHN MISTY – I LOVE YOU HONEYBEAR - CD • | $12.99 | Lunchbox Records |
| FATHER JOHN MISTY – MAHASHMASHANA - CD • | $12.99 | Lunchbox Records |
| Father John Misty - Pure Comedy | £12.99 | Dig In Records |
| Father John Misty - Pure Comedy | £13.00 | Record Revivals |
| Father John Misty – Fear Fun (CD) | $13.50 | Spin Time Records |
| FATHER JOHN MISTY – FEAR FUN | $13.99 | Get Hip Recordings! |
| Father John Misty - God's Favorite Customer [CD] | $13.99 | Out of the Past Records |
| Father John Misty - God's Favorite Customer [CD] | $13.99 | South Metro Music |
| Father John Misty - Greatish Hits CD | $13.99 | Feel It Records |
| FATHER JOHN MISTY – I LOVE YOU, HONEYBEAR | $13.99 | Get Hip Recordings! |
| Father John Misty – I Love You, Honeybear CD | $13.99 | Feel It Records |
| Father John Misty - Josh Tillman Presents: Fr. John Misty's Greatish [CD] | $13.99 | Out of the Past Records |
| Father John Misty - Mahashmashana [CD] | $13.99 | Out of the Past Records |
| FATHER JOHN MISTY – Fear Fun CD | €14.00 | Dirty Old Shop |
| Father John Misty - Fear Fun CD | $14.00 | Eroding Winds |
| Father John Misty - I Love You Honeybear | £14.00 | Record Revivals |
| FATHER JOHN MISTY – I Love You, Honeybear CD | €14.00 | Dirty Old Shop |
| Father John Misty - I Love You, Honeybear CD | $14.00 | Eroding Winds |
| Father John Misty - I Love You Honeybear [CD] | $14.00 | Seasick Records |
| Father John Misty - Mahashmashana | CA$14.00 | Phonopolis |
| Father John Misty - Mahashmashana | £14.00 | Record Revivals |
| Father John Misty - I Love You, Honeybear (CD) | $14.98 | Resident Vinyl |
| Father John Misty – Fear Fun CD | $14.99 | Feel It Records |
| FATHER JOHN MISTY – GOD'S FAVORITE CUSTOMER | $14.99 | Get Hip Recordings! |
| Father John Misty - Josh Tillman Presents: Fr. John Misty's Greatish [CD] | $14.99 | South Metro Music |
| Father John Misty - Live at Third Man Records | $14.99 | Morrow Records |
| FATHER JOHN MISTY – PURE COMEDY | $14.99 | Get Hip Recordings! |
| FATHER JOHN MISTY – GOD’S FAVORITE CUSTOMER | €15.00 | Dancing Bear |
| Father John Misty / *loser edition* Chloe And The Next 20th Century - (NM/NM) - 2xLP brand new, sealed. | $15.00 | Econo Jam Records |
| Father John Misty - Mahashmashana (New CD) | CA$15.00 | Sonic Boom |
| FATHER JOHN MISTY – PURE COMEDY | €15.00 | Dancing Bear |
| Father John Misty - Pure Comedy | £16.00 | South Records |
| Father John Misty - Mahashmashana - New CD | £16.46 | Off The Beaten Tracks |
| Father John Misty - Chloë And The Next 20th Century CD/2LP | £17.00 | Tangled Parrot |
| Father John Misty - Mahashmashana | £17.84 | Eclipse Records |
| Father John Misty - Pure Comedy (2026 Reissue) | £17.84 | Eclipse Records |
| Father John Misty - Pure Comedy - New CD | £17.84 | Off The Beaten Tracks |
| Father John Misty – Mahashmashana | €17.90 | Amadeus Dischi |
| FATHER JOHN MISTY - PURE COMEDY | £17.99 | Dreamhouse Records |
| Father John Misty - I Followed My Dreams And My Dreams Said To Crawl (Greatish Hits CD) | CA$18.99 | Red Cat Records |
| Father John Misty - I Love You, Honeybear (Single LP Remaster) | £19.21 | Eclipse Records |
| Father John Misty – Chloë and the Next 20th Century (Clear Blue Loser Edition) 2LP | CA$19.99 | Grooves e-Shop |
| FATHER JOHN MISTY – GOD'S FAVORITE CUSTOMER | $19.99 | Get Hip Recordings! |
| Father John Misty - God's Favorite Customer | CA$19.99 | Red Cat Records |
| Father John Misty - I Love You, Honeybear | CA$19.99 | Red Cat Records |
| Father John Misty - Pure Comedy | CA$19.99 | Red Cat Records |
| FATHER JOHN MISTY – FEAR FUN – (GATEFOLD) | $20.99 | Get Hip Recordings! |
| FATHER JOHN MISTY – PURE COMEDY – 2xLP (GATEFOLD) | $20.99 | Get Hip Recordings! |
| Father John Misty - Fear Fun USED VINYL | $21.95 | Sessions Vinyl Room |
| Father John Misty - Pure Comedy [2LP] | $21.99 | Morrow Records |
| Father John Misty - (PRESALE 11/6/26) I Love You, Honeybear (VINYL LP) | NEW | $22.90 | Love Vinyl Records |
| Father John Misty - Chloë and The Next 20th Century (Vinyl) | $22.99 | Square Cat Vinyl |
| Father John Misty - Father John Misty: Live at Third Man Records | £22.99 | Dreamhouse Records |
| FATHER JOHN MISTY – FEAR FUN - LP • | $22.99 | Lunchbox Records |
| FATHER JOHN MISTY – GOD'S FAVORITE CUSTOMER - LP • | $22.99 | Lunchbox Records |
| Father John Misty – “I Love You, Honeybear (2026 Reissue)” (Released 16th October 2026) | £22.99 | Pie & Vinyl |
| Father John Misty - Live At Third Man Records | $22.99 | Rollin' Records |
| Father John Misty – Fear Fun (LP) | $23.50 | Spin Time Records |
| Father John Misty - Fear Fun | $23.98 | Nice Price Books & Records |
| Father John Misty - God's Favorite Customer | $23.99 | Morrow Records |
| Father John Misty – “Live at Third Man Records” (Released 3rd July 2026) | £23.99 | Pie & Vinyl |
| Father John Misty – Chloe & The Next 20th Century (2LP) | $24.50 | Spin Time Records |
| Father John Misty - Pure Comedy - 2LP | €24.50 | Siluh Laden |
| FATHER JOHN MISTY - GREATISH HITS : I FOLLOWED MY DREAMS ... - CD | A$24.98 | Red Eye Records |
| Father John Misty - Fear Fun | $24.99 | Morrow Records |
| Father John Misty – Fear Fun LP | $24.99 | Feel It Records |
| Father John Misty - Fear Fun [LP] | $24.99 | Out of the Past Records |
| Father John Misty – God's Favorite Customer LP | $24.99 | Feel It Records |
| Father John Misty - God's Favorite Customer [LP] | $24.99 | Out of the Past Records |
| Father John Misty - God's Favorite Customer (LP) | $24.99 | Resident Vinyl |
| Father John Misty - God's Favorite Customer [LP] | $24.99 | South Metro Music |
| Father John Misty - I Love You, Honeybear (2015) - New LP Record 2025 Sub Pop Loser Edition Red Pearlescent Vinyl - Indie Rock / Folk Rock | $24.99 | Shuga Records |
| Father John Misty - I Love You, Honeybear [2LP/ Ltd Ed Colored Vinyl] | $24.99 | Morrow Records |
| Father John Misty – I Love You, Honeybear LP | $24.99 | Feel It Records |
| Father John Misty - I Love You/honeybear [LP] | $24.99 | soldoutvinylrecords |
| Father John Misty - I Love You/honeybear [LP] | $24.99 | South Metro Music |
| Father John Misty - I Love You, Honeybear (Red Vinyl) | $24.99 | Rollin' Records |
| Father John Misty - Fear Fun LP | $25.00 | Eroding Winds |
| Father John Misty - Fear Fun [LP] | $25.00 | Seasick Records |
| FATHER JOHN MISTY – GOD’S FAVORITE CUSTOMER LP | €25.00 | Dancing Bear |
| Father John Misty - God's Favorite Customer [LP] | $25.00 | Seasick Records |
| Father John Misty - Mahashmashana [CD] | A$25.95 | Rocking Horse Records |
| Father John Misty - I Love You/honeybear (LP) | $25.99 | Resident Vinyl |
| Father John Misty - I Love You Honeybear | €26.60 | RecordPusher |
| Father John Misty | Fear Fun (Vinilo) | €26.95 | Discos Alta Fidelidad |
| FATHER JOHN MISTY - GOD'S FAVORITE CUSTOMER - CD | A$26.98 | Red Eye Records |
| FATHER JOHN MISTY – PURE COMEDY - LP • | $26.99 | Lunchbox Records |
| Father John Misty - Chloe and The Next 20th Century LP | $27.00 | Eroding Winds |
| Father John Misty - Chloe & The Next 20th Century LP (Limited Clear Blue Colored Vinyl) | $27.00 | Eroding Winds |
| Father John Misty - God's Favorite Customer (LP) | CA$27.00 | Compact Music |
| Father John Misty - Pure Comedy 2xLP | $27.00 | Eroding Winds |
| Father John Misty - Chloe And The Next 20th Century | $27.98 | Nice Price Books & Records |
| Father John Misty - Chloë And The Next 20th Century | $27.99 | Saint Marie Records |
LP/EP Finder